Sign up for freeSign up

Have you been to the Grand Canyon? The present perfect vs the past simple

An A2 ESL lesson plan on the present perfect vs the past simple at the Grand Canyon: the experience first, then the details.

Grammar
The present perfect for an experience (I've been to the Grand Canyon.), the past simple for the details (I went there last year.), signal words and short answers.
Topic
Grand Canyon National Park in Arizona, where mules still carry mail to a village inside the canyon, with words such as rim, edge, mule and lodge.
Activities
A guide post to read, a talk with a mule-ride guide and a viewer's voice message to hear, self-checking drills, a chat interview, and a wheel and boxes of questions.

What's inside

  1. Chapter 1A mile deep!

    • PictureUnlock
    • Spin the wheel and answerSpin the wheelUnlock
    • Study the words: at the Grand CanyonVocabularyTry it
    • Look at the pictures and chooseChoose by pictureUnlock

  2. Chapter 2Let's read: a canyon guide

    • Look at the photo: the Grand CanyonPictureUnlock
    • Read Nora's guide postReal-life documentTry it
    • Read and mark true or falseTrue or falseUnlock
    • Read again and choose the right answerQuizUnlock

  3. Chapter 3Let's listen: mules and mail

    • Listen to Nora and FredListeningTry it
    • Transcript, for the teacherUnlock
    • Listen and choose the right answerQuizUnlock
    • Listen to the Viewer's Question: ImaniListeningUnlock
    • Transcript, for the teacherUnlock
    • Listen and mark true or falseTrue or falseUnlock

  4. Chapter 4Grammar: Have you been? When did you go?

    • Study the scheme: Have you been? When did you go?Grammar schemeTry it
    • Choose the correct optionChoose the optionUnlock
    • Fill in the gaps: present perfect or past simpleFill in the gapsTry it
    • Fill in the table: experience and detailsFill in the tableUnlock
    • Choose the right sentenceQuizUnlock

  5. Chapter 5Let's talk: on the show!

    • Choose the right replies: questions at the hotelChatTry it
    • Open a box and answer: have you been there?Open the boxUnlock

  6. Chapter 6Homework

    • Match the words and the meaningsMatchUnlock
    • Unscramble the wordsAnagramUnlock
    • Fill in the gaps with the lesson's wordsFill in the gapsUnlock
    • Choose the correct wordChoose the optionUnlock
    • Fill in the gaps: experience or details?Fill in the gapsUnlock
    • Put the words in the correct orderUnjumbleUnlock
    • Choose the right answerQuizUnlock
    • Choose the correct option: Maya's postcardChoose the optionUnlock
    • Drag the words into the gaps: Nora's message to ImaniDrag and dropUnlock

30 exercises in 6 chapters. Start a 7-day free trial to open all of them, copy any part into your own lessons, and teach the lesson live.

Vocabulary

10 words and phrases from the lesson, each with a picture and audio in edio.

+7 more with pictures and audio in the lessonMore words

  • rim
  • edge
  • bottom
  • mailbag
  • raft
  • lodge
  • shuttle bus

Grammar: present perfect vs past simple

Both tenses talk about the past, but each has its own job. The present perfect says that something happened in your life (I've been to the Grand Canyon.); the past simple says when and how (I went there last year.). On the South Rim, learners start with the experience and switch tenses for the details, read each tense's signal words and pick the short answer that fits.

Have you been there? When did you go?

The present perfect for an experience, the past simple for the details.

Two tenses, two jobs

The present perfect, have or has + past participle, gives the experience: Fred has been to the bottom many times. The past simple gives a finished time and what happened: He first went down in 2005. One trip can need both tenses, each for its own part.

Two tenses, two jobs

Present perfect: your experience (no time)

  • I've been to the Grand Canyon.
  • Have you ever ridden a mule?
  • Fred has been to the bottom many times.
  • Nora has never been here before.

Past simple: the details (when, where, how)

  • I went there last year.
  • When did you go?
  • He first went down in 2005.
  • She arrived yesterday.

Every person

WhoPresent perfect: experiencePast simple: details
II have (I've) been to Arizona.I went there last year.
youYou have (you've) ridden a mule.You rode it in May.
heHe has (he's) been to the bottom.He went there in 2005.
sheShe has (she's) seen the river.She saw it yesterday.
itIt (the mule) has carried mail.It carried mail last week.
weWe have (we've) spent a night at the bottom.We spent a night there in June.
theyThey have (they've) taken a raft trip.They took a raft trip two years ago.

Went or been? Two past forms

Many irregular verbs have two different past forms: saw, seen; rode, ridden; took, taken. Others share one: met, sent, spent. The participle goes after have, so I've went is always wrong. For a visit, use been, not gone: I've been to Arizona.

Base formPast simplePast participle
bewas / werebeen
gowentgone (for a visit, use been to)
seesawseen
rideroderidden
taketooktaken
drivedrovedriven
meetmetmet
sendsentsent
spendspentspent
flowflowedflowed

Signal words for each tense

Ever, never, before, twice and How many times…? go with the present perfect. Yesterday, last year, in 2005, two days ago and When…? signal a finished time, which always takes the past simple: I saw it yesterday, not I've seen it yesterday.

Signal words

Present perfectPast simple
ever: Have you ever been there?yesterday: I saw it yesterday.
never: I've never ridden a mule.last night / week / year: We went last year.
no time given: She's been there twice.in + a year or a month: in 2005, in June
before: Have you been here before?ago: two days ago
How many times have you been there?When did you go?

A finished time? Past simple!

With yesterday, last…, in 2005, ago and When…?, never use have / has: I saw it yesterday (not: I've seen it yesterday). Yes, I have. I went there in May (not: I have gone there in May).

Short answers: have or did?

Short answers follow the question's helper verb: Have you been to the bottom? Yes, I have. Did you ride a mule? No, I didn't. A real exchange moves from one tense to the other: Have you been there? first, then When did you go?

Questions and short answers

QuestionShort answer
Have you been to the bottom?Yes, I have. / No, I haven't.
Has Fred ridden a mule?Yes, he has. / No, he hasn't.
When did you go?I went in 2005.
Did you ride a mule?Yes, I did. / No, I didn't.

First the experience, then the details

Start with the present perfect: Have you been to the Grand Canyon? – Yes, I have. Then use the past simple for the details: When did you go? – I went last year. How did you get to the bottom? – I rode a mule. Short forms: I've = I have, he's = he has.

Common mistakes

  • I have been there last year.

    I went there last year.

    last year is a finished time: past simple

  • When have you been there?

    When did you go there?

    When…? asks for a time: past simple

  • Did you ever been to Arizona?

    Have you ever been to Arizona?

    never did + been; an experience: have + been

  • I've went there.

    I've been there. / I went there.

    have + past participle (been), not went

More lessons on this grammar: Present perfect lessons and exercises · Past simple lessons and exercises

Try the present perfect and past simple exercises

Try them yourself: these are the same exercises your students do in edio.

More exercises

What's in the lesson

  • 17 auto-checked exercises
  • 4 games
  • 1 real-life document
  • 1 grammar scheme
  • 1 set of word cards
  • 2 audio clips
  • 2 pictures
  • 2 transcripts

The main objectives of this lesson are to:

  • ask about an experience, then the details: Have you been to the Grand Canyon? When did you go?
  • give a finished time with the past simple: I went there last year. He first went down in 2005.
  • match the short answer to the question: Have you…? Yes, I have. Did you…? No, I didn't.
  • sort the signal words of each tense: ever, never, before; yesterday, last May, two years ago

Lesson 2 continues Wonders of nature, unit 1 of English A2.2 · Curious Minds. It sets the present perfect of lesson 1 (Have you ever…?, been to) beside the past simple, and brings back When…?, ago and in + a year from A2.1 lesson 7. Lesson 3 then joins the present perfect to superlatives. At the canyon, Have you been to the bottom? comes first and When did you go? follows, the order the lesson teaches.

Students spin a wheel of questions about hiking, canyons and high places, then learn ten words with pictures and audio, from spend and flow to mailbag and shuttle bus. Nora's guide post covers the canyon's size, its free shuttle buses, a hotel from 1905 and Supai, a village that still gets its mail by mule. Two AI-voiced listenings follow: Nora with Fred, a mule-ride guide who first rode down in 2005, and a viewer's voice message from Maine. After the scheme come four self-checking drills, among them a table with an experience and its details for each person. In the chat, Nora interviews the student as a front-desk worker at the old hotel, and open boxes ask about places students have been to.

Homework runs to nine self-checking exercises: a word match, an anagram, gaps for the new words, a choice of the right form, a gap-fill on experience or details, sentences to unjumble, a short-answer quiz, Maya's postcard home and Nora's message to a viewer with words to drag in.

Grammar:
present perfect vs past simple · Have you been…? Yes, I have. · When did you…? · ever / never vs yesterday, last, ago
Topic:
Grand Canyon · Arizona · national parks · mules · Phantom Ranch · mail by mule · Curious Minds

Teaching tips

  • Draw a timeline with two zones: a long bracket labeled my life so far for I've been to Arizona, and dated dots for I went there in May. Students then place two trips of their own.
  • Before the guide post, take a show of hands: who has been to a national park? Each Yes, I have gets one follow-up from the class, such as When did you go?
  • Play the guide dialogue twice: first for what Fred has done, then for dates and details, while students sort what they hear into two columns, present perfect and past simple.
  • Turn the hotel chat into a pair interview: one student works at a place they know, the other asks Have you…? questions and two past simple questions after each Yes.

Liked it?

Teach the whole lesson in edio

30 exercises in 6 chapters, ready to teach. edio is an online platform for language schools and teachers: ready-made interactive lessons, live classes, homework and student progress in one place.

  1. Start a free trial

    7 days, no credit card.

  2. Open the lesson

    Find it in the library of 621 ready lessons. Teach it as it is, or copy any chapter into your own lessons.

  3. Teach it live or as homework

    Students work in their own accounts, in sync with you during the lesson, and the practice exercises check themselves.

Teach it free for 7 days

The whole course: English A2.2 · Curious Minds

32 lessons that pick up where English A2.1 ends, in simple American English, from the present perfect to used to, have to and relative clauses. Eight units cover nature, tech at home, heroes, healthy habits, fashion, school, animals and traditions. Pictures and definitions replace translations, and the practice exercises check themselves.See the course

  1. Unit 1 Wonders of nature

    the present perfect with ever and never, been to, superlatives with I've ever, articles with place names

    1. Lesson 1Have you ever seen the sky dance?The present perfect for experiences
    2. Lesson 2 · you're hereHave you been to the Grand Canyon?Present perfect vs past simple
    3. Lesson 3The longest cave in the worldSuperlatives with the present perfect
    4. Lesson 4The first national parkArticles with place names

  2. Unit 2 Clever tech at home

    the present perfect with just, already and yet, phrasal verbs, subject and object questions

    1. Lesson 5The chocolate bar that meltedThe present perfect with just
    2. Lesson 6Has my lunch arrived yet?Already and yet with the present perfect
    3. Lesson 7Turn it on, turn it offPhrasal verbs with it and them
    4. Lesson 8The girl who tests waterSubject and object questions

  3. Unit 3 Everyday heroes

    the past continuous, when and while, adjective order, story linkers

    1. Lesson 9When the pager beepsThe past continuous with was and were
    2. Lesson 10The man who planted apple treesPast continuous and past simple with when and while
    3. Lesson 11What's in the lost and found?The order of adjectives
    4. Lesson 12The dogs who saved NomeStory linkers

  4. Unit 4 Healthy and happy habits

    will for predictions, the zero and first conditionals, so do I and neither do I

    1. Lesson 13Why does school start later in California?Will and won't for predictions, decisions and offers
    2. Lesson 14Brain freeze!The zero conditional for facts
    3. Lesson 15Doctor's orders: go to the park!The first conditional with if and will
    4. Lesson 16Walking in the mall at 7 a.m.Agreeing with So do I and Neither do I

  5. Unit 5 Style through time

    used to, didn't use to, made of and made from, still and not anymore

    1. Lesson 17Why did everyone use to wear a hat?Used to for past habits and states
    2. Lesson 18Jeans used to be work clothesUsed to in negatives and questions
    3. Lesson 19Quilts made from old clothesMade of, made from and made by
    4. Lesson 20Cowboy boots, still made by handStill, not anymore and no longer

  6. Unit 6 School in America

    have to, must and mustn't, be allowed to, had to

    1. Lesson 21Do you have to wear a uniform?Have to and don't have to for rules
    2. Lesson 22Stop for the yellow bus!Must, mustn't and don't have to
    3. Lesson 23A class trip to the SmithsonianBe allowed to and can for permission
    4. Lesson 24One room, one teacher, every gradeHad to and didn't have to for past duties

  7. Unit 7 Amazing animals

    relative clauses with which, that, who and where, look and sound + adjective, adjectives with prepositions

    1. Lesson 25The bird that copies car alarmsRelative clauses with which and that
    2. Lesson 26Alligators and crocodiles togetherWho, which, that and where in relative clauses
    3. Lesson 27Sailors thought it was a mermaidLook, sound and feel as linking verbs
    4. Lesson 28Beagles at the airportAdjectives with prepositions

  8. Unit 8 Traditions we love

    invitations, will vs going to, so and such, one and ones

    1. Lesson 29Come to our cookout!Making, accepting and refusing invitations
    2. Lesson 30Is spring going to come early?Will vs going to for the future
    3. Lesson 31From turnips to pumpkinsSo and such for emphasis
    4. Lesson 32Giant balloons over ManhattanOne and ones in place of a noun

Questions about this lesson

What's the difference between the present perfect and the past simple?
The present perfect tells that something happened; the past simple tells when and how. I've been to the Grand Canyon is an experience in your life, with no time given. I went there last year fixes it at a finished time, and the details follow in the same tense: We took a shuttle bus. The A2 lesson Have you been to the Grand Canyon? on edio.ai is built on this split.
When do you use the past simple instead of the present perfect?
Use the past simple whenever a finished time is given or asked for: yesterday, last summer, in 2005, two years ago, When…? So it's I saw it yesterday, not I've seen it yesterday, and When did you go?, not When have you been? The past simple also carries a story's details once the time is clear: How did you get to the bottom? I rode a mule.
Can you use the present perfect and the past simple together?
Yes, and they often work as a pair: the present perfect opens, the past simple follows. Have you been to the bottom of the canyon? Yes, I have. I've been there three times. When did you first go? I first went there two years ago. A chat at a hotel on the rim in Have you been to the Grand Canyon?, an A2 lesson on edio.ai, follows this pattern.
How do you know whether to use the present perfect or the past simple?
Check the sentence for a finished time: if it has one, or if the question asks When…?, use the past simple; for a life experience with no time, use the present perfect. Signal words help: ever, never, before, twice and How many times…? point to the present perfect, while yesterday, last…, in + a year and ago point to the past simple.
How do you answer "Have you been to…?"
Answer with Yes, I have or No, I haven't, then add details in the past simple: Have you been to the Grand Canyon? Yes, I have. I went there last year. Or: No, I haven't. I've never been there. Don't reply Yes, I did: that answers a past simple question, such as Did you ride a mule? For a visit, the standard form is been to: Have you been to Arizona?
Is it "I have been there last year" or "I went there last year"?
It's I went there last year, in the past simple, because last year is a finished time. The present perfect can't take a time like that, so I have been there last year and I've seen it yesterday are both wrong. To give both facts, use two sentences: I've been to the Grand Canyon. I went there last year. Yesterday, ago and in 2005 work the same way.
Is it "When have you been there?" or "When did you go there?"
Say When did you go there?, because When…? asks for a finished time, and a finished time takes the past simple. The present perfect asks whether, not when: Have you been there? A natural exchange uses both: Have you been to Phantom Ranch? Yes, I have. When did you go? In May. How many times…?, though, goes with the present perfect: How many times have you been there?
Is it "Yes, I have" or "Yes, I did"?
It depends on the question's helper verb: Have you…? takes Yes, I have or No, I haven't, and Did you…? takes Yes, I did or No, I didn't. So Have you been to the bottom? Yes, I have. But Did you ride a mule? No, I didn't. I walked down the trail. A homework quiz in Have you been to the Grand Canyon? on edio.ai offers Yes, I did as a trap.
How do I teach the present perfect vs the past simple?
Teach the two tenses as one conversation, not two separate rules: the present perfect asks and answers about the experience, and the past simple takes over for the details. Model it with a real trip, Have you been to a national park? Yes, I have. When did you go?, then sort signal words into two columns: ever and never on one side, yesterday and ago on the other.
What's a good game for practicing the present perfect and the past simple?
Try a follow-up interview game: one student asks a Have you ever…? question from a box or a wheel, and every Yes, I have must be followed by two past simple questions, such as When did you go? and Did you like it? A wrong tense loses the point. One open box in this lesson asks for two places you've been to and one you've never been to.
What's good homework for practicing the present perfect and past simple?
Good homework makes the time words decide the tense: gaps where last October or three times settles the form, short answers to choose and sentences to unjumble. In the A2 lesson Have you been to the Grand Canyon? on edio.ai, all nine homework exercises check themselves, ending with Maya's postcard to her mom and Nora's reply to a viewer, with words to drag in.
Are there interactive exercises for the present perfect and past simple?
Yes: tense-choice gap-fills and chat role-plays show whether a learner picked the right form. Without an account, this page plays four parts of Have you been to the Grand Canyon?, an A2 lesson on edio.ai: Nora's guide post from the South Rim, her talk with a mule-ride guide, a gap-fill that mixes has been with rode and spent, and a chat in which students play a hotel worker answering Nora's questions. The other exercises are locked.
Unlock full lesson

Teach this lesson with your students

Book a demoStart free trial

No credit card required